Temp Staffing vs Permanent Employment: Making the Right Decision

Hospitality

Temp Staffing vs Permanent Employment: Making the Right Decision

Daniel Johnson

/

September 6, 2024

The heartbeat of the hospitality industry relies on exceptional service and seamless operations. As hotels, restaurants, and event venues seek to staff their teams effectively, a crucial decision emerges: should they opt for temporary staffing or permanent hiring?

If you’re in the process of planning staff for your organization and you’re not sure whether you should hire temp of full-time, we can help! Learn more about GravyWork and our mission to make hospitality staffing the easiest part of your operation!

Temporary Staffing in Hospitality: The Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Flexibility When It Matters Most: The hospitality industry experiences fluctuating demands due to seasons, holidays, and events. Temporary staffing offers unmatched flexibility, allowing businesses to swiftly adjust their workforce based on occupancy levels and special occasions.
  • Cost-Efficiency During Peaks: Temporary staff can be a cost-effective solution during high-demand periods, avoiding the long-term financial commitments of permanent hires, including benefits and training costs.
  • Try Before You Commit: Temporary positions in hospitality can serve as a trial period for potential permanent hires. This firsthand experience enables employers to assess skills, customer service aptitude, and compatibility with the team and company culture.

Cons:

  • Inconsistent Loyalty: Temporary staff might lack the same level of dedication to the brand as permanent employees, potentially affecting guest experience and service quality.
  • Training Challenges: Frequent turnover due to temporary staffing can result in a constant cycle of training, diverting resources from other critical operations.
  • Team Cohesion: Relying heavily on temporary staff might hinder the development of a cohesive team and shared camaraderie among employees.

Permanent Hiring in Hospitality: The Pros and Cons

Pros:

  • Consistent Guest Relations: Permanent employees are better positioned to establish strong guest relations and deliver personalized service through repeated interactions.
  • Stable Team Dynamics: A permanent workforce fosters stable team dynamics, leading to improved collaboration and a more welcoming atmosphere for guests.
  • Nurturing Expertise: Permanent employees have the chance to develop specialized skills over time, contributing to improved efficiency and a better guest experience.

Cons:

  • Initial Financial Investment: Permanent hiring requires a higher initial financial commitment due to salaries, benefits, and potential recruitment expenses.
  • Flexibility Challenges: Permanent employees might struggle to adapt to sudden changes in demand or special events, leading to staffing gaps or excess labor during slow periods.
  • Hiring Uncertainties: Committing to permanent hires without a proper trial period could result in mismatches between employees' skills and the demands of the role.

Navigating the Decision in the Hospitality Industry

In the hospitality realm, the choice between temporary staffing and permanent hiring is nuanced. For seasonal peaks and events, temporary staffing can ensure flexibility and cost-efficiency. However, for roles that directly impact guest experience and require consistent service, permanent hires may be a more reliable option.

To strike a balance, consider using temporary positions as an evaluation phase for potential permanent employees. This strategy allows you to gauge a candidate's performance in a real-world setting before extending a full-time offer, minimizing the risk of a poor fit.

In the hospitality industry, the staffing choice between temporary and permanent is a pivotal one. By tailoring your decision to the unique demands of your business, you can strike the right balance between flexibility and stability, cost-efficiency and guest satisfaction. Whether you're navigating seasonal rushes or aiming for lasting guest relations, the right staffing approach can define the success of your hospitality business.

If you’re looking for temp staffing support for your hospitality organization, we’re happy to help! GravyWork leverages technology to ensure a fast & easy experience without forgetting the human element. Each customer has a dedicated account manager to ensure you have an amazing experience working with us. Schedule a demo today!

The New VIP Experience: Training On-Demand Staff for High-End Service
On-demand workers are qualified professionals, and they often have extensive experience. However,they still need to be trained in the way that you do things, and if you offer ahigh-end, luxury service, such training is imperative.
Weather-Proof Your Events: Staffing Strategies for Outdoor Venues
There’s no such thing as bad weather, only poor preparation. It’s often considered to be one of the only factors that you can’t control when staging an outdoor event, but while it’s true that you can’t shoo those rainclouds away, you can implement some strategies to mitigate the risks.
Menu Engineering Meets Staffing: Aligning Your Workforce with Food Service Demands
Throwing a big event and want to make a splash? The food and drinks you serve are obviously a big part of it, but the people making that food and serving those drinks can be just as important.
Multi-Venue Management: MasteringStaff Distribution Across Multiple Locations
Managing multiple venues and teams? It’s tough, with various challenges to overcome and pitfalls to avoid. However, with the tips outlined on this page, you can effectively manage those teams, deal with whatever issues come your way, and keep the profits flowing.
ROI of Flexible Staffing: A CFO's Guide to Cost-Effective Workforce Management
Flexible staffing is a cost-effective way to manage your workforce. You hire on-demand as you need them and don’t need to worry about long-term commitments, benefits, and other extraneous costs. If utilized properly, an emergency staffing solution can significantly improve your bottom line.
Emergency Staffing: Creating a Bulletproof Backup Plan for No-Shows
Even the most dedicated and professional staff members can fail to show up for work, and in the hospitality industry, absences are also very common among attendees. It’s not always their fault, and it’s hard to predict such outcomes, but if you create a backup plan, you can prepare for those no-shows and ensure your team stays strong and the day runs smoothly.
GravyWork Mobile App

Work local jobs near you and get paid weekly.

Join over 10,000 workers who use GravyWork to find jobs at near your living place.